Candy Battle 2023 Begins: Payday vs. 3 Musketeers

Payday

90
points

3 Musketeers

82
points

Halloween is just around the corner, and the temptation of sweet treats can be hard to resist. We're putting your favorite candies head-to-head in Signos’ Candy Battle series to help you navigate this spooky season.

Salad bowl on a white polygonal plate.

Discover how your body responds to what you eat, and make small changes to hit your health goals

Payday

3 Musketeers

Serving Size
1 full-size bar
1 full-size bar
Calories
240
240
Fat
13g
7 g
Carbohydrates
27 g
42 g
Sugars
21 g
37 g
Protein
7 g
1 g
HeaderHeaderHeader
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell
CellCellCell

Payday vs. 3 Musketeers Overview

In the first matchup, it's Payday vs. 3 Musketeers!

Payday

Payday, famous for its hearty peanut center, packs 7 grams of protein and 2 grams of fiber. Dietary fiber can help keep blood sugar levels in check by slowing the absorption of sugar from the intestine. This is not only helpful for people with diabetes or prediabetes, but for anyone interested in keeping blood sugar stable.

While Payday does offer some benefits, this candy bar still contains added sugars that can impact your blood sugar.

3 Musketeers

Meet its opponent, 3 Musketeers, with its fluffy nougat core. Unfortunately, it contains a significant amount of hydrogenated oils, also known as trans fats, which aren't great for heart health. Trans fats have no known health benefits and there is no safe level of consumption.

While this candy contains less fat than Payday, it does contain significantly more carbs and sugar. 

Sweet Victory

In the first showdown, Payday emerges as the victor due to its higher protein and fiber content. Enjoy it in moderation, keeping an eye on added sugars. 

As Halloween night creeps closer, make informed treat choices by balancing protein, fiber, and fats for blood sugar stability. Be on the lookout for more epic candy showdowns and expert tips to sweeten your journey to better health!

Pro Tip: Opt for Fruit

Often called nature’s candy, fruit can help satisfy even the most stubborn sweet tooths. Low-glycemic index (low GI) fruits contain less fructose (a naturally occurring sugar found in fruits) than others. They are rich in fiber, slowing digestion and decreasing the risk of “peaks and valleys” in your bloodstream.

Frequent swings in your blood sugar levels can leave you feeling physically and mentally exhausted. The high fiber content contributes to bathroom regularity, heart health protection, reduced risk of certain cancers, and satiety.

Try dipping strawberries or apples in dark chocolate this Halloween if you want a healthy substitute.

Salad bowl on a white polygonal plate.

Discover how your body responds to what you eat, and make small changes to hit your health goals

Frequently Asked Questions

If you have any questions left, please keep reading! Below, we answer frequently asked questions regarding healthiness level and nutrient intake:

Can I enjoy candy on a diet?

While it might seem contradictory, incorporating candy into a balanced eating plan is entirely possible. Doing so can help satisfy your sweet tooth while maintaining overall health and well-being.

The foundation of a healthy diet is balance. Balance means eating various nutrient-rich foods that provide your body with the essential vitamins, minerals, and energy it needs to thrive, plus making mindful choices to enjoy the occasional sweet treat without compromising your overall nutrition.

What are the best alternatives for candy?

One of our favorite candy alternatives is fruit. Fresh fruit is naturally sweet and packed with fiber, vitamins, and minerals.

No items found.