Instacart Review: Pros, Cons, and Is It Worth the Price?

Key Takeaways

• Instacart saves time and offers convenience, but it comes at a price.
• It’s most worth it for busy people who value time and convenience over saving money.
• Grocery delivery may support healthier choices and reduce impulse buys.

that {{mid-cta}}

Modern conveniences are changing the way we handle everyday tasks, including grocery shopping. In 2024, 51.8% of adults in the U.S. purchased groceries online.¹ With services like Instacart, groceries from stores like Costco, Kroger (or maybe Ralph’s near you), and Aldi can arrive at your door in just a few hours, no crowded aisles or checkout lines required.

The convenience is hard to ignore. But so are the added fees. In this Instacart review, we’ll break down how the service works, what it really costs, and when it makes sense to use. That way, you can decide if it fits your routine, budget, and health goals.

What Is Instacart and How Does It Work?

Instacart is a grocery delivery and pickup service that lets you shop from local stores through a mobile app or website. Instead of heading to the store yourself, a personal shopper selects your items, checks out, and delivers them straight to your door.

The platform connects you with a wide range of retailers, including major grocery chains, pharmacies, and pet stores, making it easy to order everything from fresh produce to household essentials in one place. Delivery is often available within one to two hours and, in some areas, can arrive in as little as 30 minutes, making it one of the fastest grocery delivery options available.

How Instacart Works in 4 Simple Steps

1. Choose your store. Open the Instacart app or website and select from nearby grocery stores, pharmacies, and specialty shops.
2. Add items to your cart. Browse aisles just like you would in-store and add groceries, household essentials, or pet supplies to your cart.
3. A personal shopper fills your order. Once you place your order, a shopper picks your items, communicates via chat if substitutions are needed or if something is out of stock, and checks out for you.
4. Get groceries delivered (or picked up). Your order is delivered straight to your door, often within one to two hours, or you can choose curbside pickup at the store.

Instacart Pricing: What Does It Really Cost?

While Instacart saves time, that convenience comes at a price, and it’s often higher than many people expect. In addition to the cost of your groceries, several extra charges can quickly increase your total. Let’s break it down:

• Higher item prices. Many products are priced higher than in-store, meaning you’re paying a markup on everyday staples before fees are even added. Some retailers, like Walmart, match their in-store prices.
• Delivery fees. Delivery fees typically start around $3.99 for purchases over $35. Faster delivery, smaller orders, and longer trips often come with higher fees. A $10-$35 minimum order applies, and smaller orders may trigger additional charges that quickly raise your total.
• Service fees. Instacart charges a variable service fee (typically around 5% or more of your order total) to cover operating costs like shopper support, insurance, and background checks. The fee may vary based on location, order size, item type, and order adjustments. Instacart+ members may receive reduced service fees, though other charges can still apply.
• Tipping your shopper. Tips aren’t required, but most customers include one to thank shoppers for their time and effort, which increases the final price of each order.

Instacart+ Membership

Instacart+ (formerly called Instacart Express) is a premium subscription that costs $99 per year or $9.99 per month. Members receive $0 delivery fees on eligible orders (typically $35 or more for groceries and around $10 or more for some retailers) along with reduced service fees compared to non-members.

The membership also includes a few added perks, such as family sharing with another household member, a free Peacock Premium subscription, and one year of New York Times Cooking. Some users may also receive promotional credits on qualifying orders.

New members are usually offered a 14-day free trial, which can help them test whether the savings outweigh the monthly or annual cost.

Pros of Using Instacart

For many people, Instacart’s biggest advantage is the time it saves, but the benefits go beyond convenience alone.

• Saves time. Forget driving time, hectic parking lots, and waiting in checkout lines; groceries are delivered directly to your door, and you have more time for work, family, or rest.
• It’s helpful for busy schedules and limited mobility. Parents juggling activities, professionals with packed calendars, and people who have difficulty getting to the store often find grocery delivery makes weekly routines much easier.
• You can shop multiple stores in one app.
  Instacart allows you to order from different retailers in a single place (from grocery stores to pharmacies and specialty shops), so you don’t have to drive all around town.
• Reordering staples is quick and easy. The app saves your past purchases, so it’s easy to restock common items in just a few taps.
• Delivery and curbside pickup add flexibility. If you want to skip delivery fees, curbside pickup still saves time while keeping costs lower than home delivery.

Cons of Using Instacart

While Instacart can be a major time-saver, it does come with a few downsides to consider.

• It often increases your grocery bill. Between item markups, delivery fees, service fees, and tips, most shoppers end up paying more than they would in-store, especially with frequent or smaller orders.
• You have less control over produce selection. Personal shoppers do their best, but you may not always get the exact ripeness or quality you would choose yourself.
• Substitutions aren’t always ideal. When items are out of stock, replacement products may not match your preferences or dietary needs, even with settings in place.
• Tipping adds another layer of cost. While tipping is optional, it’s customary, and a nice gesture of thanks to your shopper, one that can noticeably increase your final total.
• It’s not always cost-effective for small orders. Smaller carts often trigger higher fees, making delivery more expensive than a simple in-store trip.

Is Instacart Worth the Price?

Deciding whether Instacart is worth the cost depends on how much you value time and convenience compared to saving money.

Often worth it for:

• Busy professionals who don’t have time for regular grocery trips
• Parents with tight schedules juggling work, school, and activities
• People without easy access to stores, whether due to transportation or mobility limitations

For these groups, the time saved each week can outweigh the cost of additional fees.
‍

May be less ideal for:

• Budget-focused shoppers who are trying to keep grocery costs as low as possible
• People who enjoy choosing their own produce and deals in-store

Ultimately, Instacart is a classic cost-versus-convenience trade-off. It can make life easier and routines smoother, but most shoppers will pay more for that simplicity.

Tips to Save Money on Instacart

While Instacart isn’t the cheapest way to shop for groceries, using it strategically can help keep costs from climbing too high.

• Use Instacart+ only if you order frequently. The membership can lower delivery and service fees, but it’s most worthwhile for people who place larger orders regularly.
• Build bigger, less frequent orders. To avoid the fees associated with smaller orders, plan one larger weekly order.
• Avoid peak delivery times. Schedule orders during off-peak hours to help reduce costs.
• Look for stores that match in-store pricing.
• Customize substitution preferences. Choose replacements to avoid overpriced or unwanted substitutions when items are unavailable.
• Watch for store deals and promotions. Instacart frequently features store-specific discounts and limited-time offers that can help offset fees.

How Grocery Delivery Can Impact Eating Habits

Research suggests that shopping for groceries online is often linked to slightly healthier food choices. Compared to in-store shoppers, people ordering online tend to spend more on foods like fruits, vegetables, and whole grains, and make fewer impulse purchases, such as sugary drinks or snack foods that are easy to grab at checkout.^2,3

One reason may be planning. Online shopping encourages building a list ahead of time rather than browsing aisles, which can make it easier to stick to intentional food choices.

That said, the impact isn’t the same for everyone. In areas with access to grocery stores and fresh foods, delivery services may support healthier purchasing habits. In communities with limited food options, online platforms can sometimes promote more processed or convenience foods, especially if healthier items are harder to find or less visible in the app.⁴

The Bottom Line

Instacart saves time and makes grocery shopping more convenient, but most shoppers end up paying more because of item markups, delivery fees, service fees, and tips. For busy professionals, parents, and people with limited access to stores, the time savings may be worth the added cost, while budget-focused shoppers may prefer to shop in-store. When used intentionally, Instacart can support meal planning and reduce impulse purchases.

Learn More With Signos’ Expert Advice

Signos helps people improve their health by combining smart food logging, 24/7 glucose monitoring, and access to registered dietitians. Find out how glucose impacts health on Signos’ blog.